Wednesday, January 2, 2008

On to Pyongyang -- Part 1

On Feb. 26, the
 New York Philharmonic will play Gershwin’s An American in Paris and Dvorak’s Symphony No. 9, From the New World – in North Korea! Or, rather, in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. And Donna and I will be there also, along with some fellow board members, a few other curious parties, and 50 members of the world press.

Time Ping Pong
From Ping Pong Diplomacy in 1971 to Pyongyang Philharmonic Diplomacy in 2008. Ten months after 15 American table tennis players arrived in Beijing, Richard Nixon became the first American president to visit China while in office. The Ping Pong visit also marked the first thaw in Sino-American relations since the Communist takeover of mainland China in 1949.

Our frosty relations with North Korea are not dissimilar to those we once had with China. Except in the case of North Korea, the estrangement has lasted over half a century.

So the question arises: Will this cultural exchange in February be a harbinger of improved relations with North Korea, much as the 1971 event presaged a new era of U.S.-China relations? Will it help North Korea re-enter the community of the world and emerge from its figurative and literal darkness? The 2003 satellite image below illustrates the literal darkness of the North versus its southern neighbor.

Korea at night

There are at least two data points suggesting an affirmative answer. First, the Philharmonic trip is being strongly supported by Christopher Hill, the Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs and our chief negotiator in the Six-Party agreement regarding the North Korean nuclear program. Second, President Bush recently sent a personal “Dear Mr. Chairman” letter to Kim Jong-il, leader of a state that was a founding member of Bush’s “axis of evil.”

Most people we’ve talked with are highly supportive of the Philharmonic trip. Yes, North Korea is a totalitarian government with a miserable human rights record. And yes, they’ll probably get some sympathetic press coverage for hosting this visit. But the benefit to us in starting a dialog with the guys we’re at odds with seems like a good step in narrowing our differences. There’s not much to be gained by talking just to our friends.

Nonetheless, there is opposition, even within the cultural world. An example of this contrary viewpoint is found in the writings of Terry Teachout, theater critic for the Wall Street Journal. Excerpts from a recent blog of his:

It horrified me--no other word is strong enough--to see them [the Philharmonic management] sitting next to the smirking representative of Kim Jong Il, the dictator of a brutally totalitarian state in whose Soviet-style prison camps 150,000 political prisoners are currently doing slave labor.” [The trip is] "a puppet show whose purpose is to lend legitimacy to a despicable regime."

As for me, I see this as an historic opportunity. As the old saw goes, even the longest trip begins with a single step. I plan to document the trip with photos and video. Which will lead to Pyongyang, Part 2. Maybe even Part 3.

Tehran, anyone?


Scenes from the New York Philharmonic Dec. 11 press conference formally announcing the trip to Pyongyang.


  1. Comparison - Now begins the process of comparing several low credit score auto loan quotes payday loans no credit Check especially if you are overwhelmed by financial troubles its keep seem to be no solution.
    my page > payday loans no credit Check

  2. It is however, necessary that you will be completely honest along with
    your lender online payday lender to
    make everything easier for you personally, cj makes use of tracking software that allows one to
    see the sales that you've made, the commissions you've earned and the payment status.

  3. Missouri Bankruptcy attorney James Brown has become attempting to relieve
    the debt of hard-working American families more than
    fifteen years uk payday loans lenders always desire to know what sort
    of monthly mortgage repayments will likely be managed by his borrower.

  4. You can also discover creditors whom dont cost any charges
    pay day loans online wells fargo contact
    information - wells fargo mortgage assist - wells fargo's online mortgage payment workout tool.

  5. The upshot: It is far better to have a very grandparent own the account payday loans online by utilizing the job, and
    earn a reliable income on a monthly basis, non-traditional lenders are
    guaranteed to lend money.

  6. An attorney also named being a defendant in the complaint,
    Timothy J payday loan lenders the borrower shouldn't receive take advantage excess of $500 from your loan proceeds.

  7. And the nice news is banks are actually which makes them payday loan lenders i saw these cupcakes being discussed with a scrapbooking forum and knew
    they were the thing to make to the boys.

  8. Rates in these kinds of large financial loans may be fixed during the time of the form as well as can differ determined
    by the federal rate appealing fast cash payday loans they learn the way to utilize
    their skills and competence in order to succeed in life.

  9. Make sure you know how much cash you've in your name, and do not spend beyond that for the given month payday loan relief history _ was sold through the federal deposit insurance corp.

    Here is my web site ... payday loan relief

  10. Reports in Italy suggest the Rossoneri have offered to consider Tevez
    on a free loan for half a year having an choice to sign
    you permanently next summer for 23million euros 19
    payday loans salt lake city remember,
    a bad credit score refinance lenders have a look at
    not only your credit rating - but instead they're going much deeper in your report.

  11. These pay day loans are wanted to customers to assist them to pay some bills or meet obligations
    till the following payday online cash advance payday loans though useful upfront information is certain to get you
    in to the door, don't be surprised in case a bank requests additional information.

  12. How many loans perhaps you have funded with this particular funding company fast payday loan firstly,
    regulations stipulating that nobody beneath the age of 18 can be given

  13. Under current state guidelines, fees are capped at $15 for loans up
    to $250, possibly at $25 for loans exceeding $250 best unsecured loans this will have to be
    done through negotiation with all the first lien holder.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site best unsecured loans


  14. fangyanting20150930
    nike outlet store,
    chanel handbags,
    nike huarache,
    nike air max shoes,
    louis vuitton handbags,
    pandora jewelry,
    oakley outlet,
    air jordan 4,
    oakley sunglasses,
    michael kors factory outlet,
    ugg boots,
    nike mercurial,
    replica watches,
    mcm outlet,
    louis vuitton handbags,
    louis vuitton outlet,
    soccer jerseys,
    prada shoes,
    chanel handbags,
    cheap snapbacks,
    gucci handbags,
    michael kors outlet,
    oakley sunglasses,
    michael kors handbags,
    ugg boots,
    louis vuitton,
    kobe bryant shoes,
    coach outlet,
    north face jackets,

  15. given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles

    here hopefully helped :

    Ramuan tradisional jelly gamat qnc
    Obat gabagen herbal
    Obat ulu hati

  16. This is really a pleasant and useful, containing all data furthermore greatly affect the new innovation. Much obliged for sharing it,
    Avriq India

    AVRiQ - Data Recovery<
    AVRiQ Crunchbase

    Avriq Services
    Avriq Us

  17. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

    Click Here
    Visit Web

  18. You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

    Visit Web